Monografias

Este material pode ser reproduzido desde que citadas a fonte e as
referências bibliográficas de acordo com as normas vigentes.


Título Desmistificando o Instituto: a súmula vinculante é eficaz?
Autor Letícia Oliveira Lins de Alencar
Ano 2010
Orientador André de Albuquerque Cavalcanti Abbud
Palavras-chave Súmula Vinculante; STF; descumprimento; eficácia; reclamação; EC 45/04
Acórdãos citados Decisões liminares: Rcl 5.460/SP; Rcl 5.508/SP; Rcl 8.226/DF; Rcl 7.411/DF; Rcl 6.224/SP; Rcl 8.858/SC; Rcl 9.888/RS; Rcl 9.455/SP; Rcl 9.399/PI; Rcl 9.330/SC; Rcl 8.954/SC; Rcl 8.975/SC; Rcl 8.559/SP; Rcl 8.976/SP; Rcl 8.949/SP; Rcl 8.489/SP; Rcl 7.992/SP; Rcl 7.945/SP; Rcl 8082/SP; Rcl 8091/SC; Rcl 7870/RS; Rcl 7.521/DF; Rcl 7.797/PR; Rcl 7.798/PR; Rcl 7.795/PR; Rcl 7.709/MA; Rcl 7.601/MG; Rcl 6.873/SP; Rcl 6830/PR; Rcl 6.513/RS; Rcl 7.802/PR; Rcl 6.513/RS; Rcl 9.888/RS; Rcl 8.362/RS; Rcl 6.725/SP; Rcl 6.277/DF; Rcl 6.266/DF; Rcl 9.337/SP; Rcl 9.228/SP; Rcl 9.119/SP; Rcl 9.141/SP; Rcl 9.142/SP; Rcl 9.107/SP; Rcl 9.339/SP; Rcl 9.120/SP; Rcl 8.827/SP; Rcl 8.939/MG; Rcl 8.895/RJ; Rcl 8.813/PA; Rcl 7.820/SP; Rcl 6.626/DF; Rcl 7.729/MA; Rcl 9.890/SP; Rcl 10.145/RS; Rcl 9.749/SP; Rcl 9.008/RS; Rcl 9.291/SP; Rcl 9.288/SP; Rcl 9.287/SP; Rcl 8.966/RS; Rcl 9.290/SP; Rcl 8.321/SP; Rcl 7.556/SP; Rcl 8.061/SP; Rcl 7.105/SP; Rcl 7.826/SP; Rcl 6.859/SP; Rcl 6.738/SP; Rcl 7.245/SP; Rcl 7.099/SP; Rcl 7.100/SP; Rcl 7.101/SP; Rcl 6.950/SP; Rcl 6.946/SP; Rcl 6.541/SP; Rcl 6.739/SP; Rcl 6.857/SP; Rcl 6.970/SP; Rcl 7.058/SP; Rcl 6.776/PE; Rcl 7.128/SP; Rcl 7.136/RJ; Rcl 7.248/SP; Rcl 7.322/DF; Rcl 7.243/ SP; Rcl 7.359/SP; Rcl 7.127/SP; Rcl 7.219/MG; Rcl 7.596/PE; Rcl 7.427/DF; Rcl 6.944/DF; Rcl 7.653/DF; Rcl 7.809/RO; Rcl 7.711/RO; Rcl 7.651/PE; Rcl 7.665/AM; Rcl 7.856/MG; Rcl 7.901/AM; Rcl 8.037/AL; Rcl 7.888/ES; Rcl 8.216/MG; Rcl 7.734/RJ; Rcl 6.650/PR; Rcl 8.205/AM; Rcl 8.187/AM; Rcl 8.273/RJ; Rcl 8.353/RJ; Rcl 8.412/CE; Rcl 8.282/SP; Rcl 8.630/MG; Rcl 9.172/PE; Rcl 9.472/CE; Rcl 9.195/SP; Rcl 8.913/RJ; Rcl 9.169/AM; Rcl 8.908/PE; Rcl 8.959/SC; Rcl 9.809/RJ; Rcl 9.192/SP Rcl 8.905/RJ; Rcl 7.046/SP; Rcl 6.962/ SP; Rcl 6.919/DF; Rcl 7.165/SP; Rcl 7.562/RJ; Rcl 7.116/PE; Rcl 7.814/RJ; Rcl 7.437/SP; Rcl 8.084/MS; Rcl 8.032/SP; Rcl 8.945/ GO; Rcl 9.880/PR; Rcl 8.409/MG; Rcl 7.831/PA; Rcl 8.295/RS; Rcl 8.596/CE; Rcl 6.702/ PR; Rcl 6.686/RN; Rcl 7.049/RS; Rcl 7.590/PR; Rcl 7.952/PI; Rcl 7.048/PI; Rcl 7.911/SP; Rcl 7.602/PR; Rcl 8.005/SC; Rcl 7.834/CE; Rcl 8.019/RO; Rcl 8.294/SC;Rcl 8.375/GO; Rcl 9.013/PI; Rcl 9.075/SP; Rcl 9.098/SP; Rcl 9.284/SP; Rcl 8.914/MG; Rcl 8.998/SP; Rcl 9.111/RS; Rcl 9.648/MG; Rcl 9.853/RJ; Rcl 7.821/RJ; Rcl 7.873/RJ; Rcl 7.893/BA; Rcl 7.813/RJ; Rcl 8.159/RS; Rcl 8.225/SC; Rcl 8.555/MG; Rcl 8.384/PR; Rcl 8.693/SP; Rcl 8.158/SP; Rcl 8.671/RS; Rcl 8.483/SP. Decisões definitivas: Rcl 9.426/SP; Rcl 9.134/RJ; Rcl 5.707/SP; Rcl 5.652/MG; Rcl 5.315/PB; Rcl 5.601/SP; Rcl 5.422/SP; Rcl 5.423/SP; Rcl 5.600/SP; Rcl 5.421/SP; Rcl 5.401/SP; Rcl 5.343/SP; Rcl 6.723/PR; Rcl 9.778/RJ; Rcl 8.947/AP; Rcl 6.723/PR; Rcl 8.235/DF; Rcl 7.782/RS; Rcl 7.096/RJ; Rcl 7.000/DF; Rcl 6.420/DF; Rcl 8.663/RS; Rcl 8.111/SP; Rcl 9.653/RO; Rcl 8.974/SC; Rcl 6.760/RS; Rcl 9.445/RS; Rcl 9.409/RS; Rcl 8.381/SC; Rcl 6.931/SP; Rcl 8.643/SC; Rcl 9.163/RS; Rcl 7.724/SP; Rcl 10.039/SP; Rcl 6.923/SP; Rcl 8.250/SP; Rcl 9.451/RS; Rcl 9.444/RS; Rcl 6.871/SP; Rcl 9.452/SC; Rcl 8.682/RS; Rcl 8.426/SP; Rcl 7.579/DF; Rcl 8.287/MG; Rcl 8.871/SP; Rcl 6.368/SC; Rcl 6.417/RS; Rcl 6.833/PR; Rcl 7.724/SP; Rcl 7.519/CE; Rcl 7.803/PR; Rcl 8.317/SP; Rcl 8.979/SP; Rcl 9.638/RS; Rcl 8.658/SP; Rcl 9.400/PI; Rcl 8.896/SP; Rcl 9.444/RS; Rcl 9.425/RS; Rcl 9.452/SC; Rcl 8.682/RS; Rcl 8.426/SP; Rcl 8.871/SP; Rcl 8.579/SC; Rcl 7.723/SP; Rcl 6.831/PR; Rcl 8.164/SP; Rcl 7.799/PR; Rcl 7.801/PR; Rcl 7.796/PR; Rcl 6.174/RS; Rcl 7.833/GO; Rcl 7.440/MG; Rcl 6.832/PR; Rcl 6.514/RS; Rcl 6.786/CE; Rcl 9.122/SP; Rcl 9.225/SP; Rcl 9.198/SP; Rcl 9.229/SP; Rcl 9.338/SP; Rcl 9.202/SP; Rcl 9.739/SP; Rcl 9.636/SP; Rcl 8.824/SP; Rcl 10.037/SP; Rcl 9.635/SP; Rcl 9.140/SP; Rcl 8.828/SP; Rcl 8.830/SP; Rcl 8.359/SP; Rcl 9.227/SP; Rcl 9.167/SP; Rcl 8.360/SP; Rcl 9.283/SP; Rcl 9.199/SP; Rcl 6.232/SP; Rcl 6.192/CE; Rcl 9.138/SP; Rcl 8.944/GO; Rcl 7.350/RN; Rcl 7.551/SP; Rcl 9.246/MT; Rcl 8.341/PB; Rcl 7.793/PR; Rcl 6.636/DF; Rcl 7.791/PA; Rcl 7.313/SP; Rcl 6.916/GO; Rcl 7.940/PA; Rcl 7.981/PA; Rcl 7.979/PA; Rcl 7.253/DF; Rcl 7.170/PE; Rcl 9.110/RS; Rcl 8.961/SP; Rcl 9.322/MS; Rcl 6.752/SP; Rcl 6.854/SP; Rcl 6.852/SP; Rcl 6.780/SP; Rcl 6.737/SP; Rcl 6.791/SP; Rcl 6.947/SP; Rcl 7.680/SP; Rcl 7.712/RO; Rcl 8.602/AM; Rcl 7.962/AM; Rcl 8.597/AM; Rcl 10.068/GO; Rcl 10.114/MT; Rcl 6.525/PR; Rcl 6.665/SP; Rcl 8.179/RS; Rcl 8.233/TO; Rcl 8.389/PE; Rcl 5.393/PA; Rcl 8.417/RO; Rcl 8.144/PE; Rcl 9.016/RO; Rcl 8.889/PE; Rcl 9.752/PE; Rcl 7.859/SP; Rcl 9.909/AM; Rcl 9.894/RO; Rcl 8.605/MG; Rcl 9.740/SP; Rcl 9.459/RO; Rcl 6.763/SP; Rcl 9.293/SP; Rcl 9.353/DF; Rcl 9.321/RJ; Rcl 9.679/PI; Rcl 9.392/SP; Rcl 7.665/AM; Rcl 7.965/SP; Rcl 8.791/MG; Rcl 9.236/RS; Rcl 6.806/SE; Rcl 8.267/SP; Rcl 8.547/SE; Rcl 9.327/RJ; Rcl 8.847/ES; Rcl 7.006/RJ; Rcl 6.771/SP; Rcl 7.223/DF; Rcl 8.272/DF; Rcl 8.223/SP; Rcl 7.774/AL; Rcl 8.154/SE; Rcl 8.204/AM; Rcl 8.180/SP; Rcl 7.925/RJ; Rcl 8.134/AM; Rcl 7.371/SP; Rcl 7.847/RO; Rcl 6.396/DF; Rcl 6.449/RS; Rcl 7.971/PA; Rcl 7.993/RJ; Rcl 8.020/SP; Rcl 7.900/RJ; Rcl 7.298/SP; Rcl 6.863/BA; Rcl 6.875/RJ; Rcl 6.709/SP; Rcl 7.740/AM; Rcl 7.218/AM; Rcl 5.395/PA; Rcl 5.400/SP; Rcl 6.638/DF; Rcl 6.702/PR; Rcl 8.846/SP; Rcl 65.413/SP; Rcl 7.182/PE; Rcl 10.177/DF; Rcl 9.092/PA; Rcl 6.969/SP; Rcl 10248/SP; Rcl 9469/RJ; Rcl 9877/DF; Rcl 9743/SP; Rcl 9692/SP; Rcl 9470/RJ; Rcl 9613/SP; Rcl 9632/SP; Rcl 9420/RJ; Rcl 9276/PR; Rcl 6565/DF; Rcl 9086/PA; Rcl 7574/SP; Rcl 8148/RJ; Rcl 7926/MG; Rcl 7819/DF; Rcl 7570/PR; Rcl 6781/PA; Rcl 6540/DF; Rcl 6928/PR; Rcl 7943/SP; Rcl 7675/MT; Rcl 7046/SP; Rcl 7361/SP; Rcl 6564/DF; Rcl 6797/DF; Rcl 7268/DF; Rcl 6963/SP; Rcl 6870/GO; Rcl 6493/SP; Rcl 9419/RJ; Rcl 7961/MG; Rcl 8625/MG; Rcl 9686/SP; Rcl 7059/MS; Rcl 9800/MG; Rcl 6582/SP; Rcl 9316/SP; Rcl 6207/PR; Rcl 8452/MA; Rcl 6650/PR; Rcl 7014/PI; Rcl 8101/SP; Rcl 6838/DF; Rcl 6915/SP; Rcl 8006/SC; Rcl 7939/RJ; Rcl 7679/SC; Rcl 8224/SP; Rcl 8483/SP; Rcl 8529/MS; Rcl 8219/AM; Rcl 7825/SP; Rcl 8073/MS; Rcl 8319/SC; Rcl 8173/SP; Rcl 7983/PE; Rcl 7902/SP; Rcl 9731/SC; Rcl 9706/MS; Rcl 9629/SP; Rcl 9677/ES; Rcl 7756/PE; Rcl 9786/SP; Rcl 9857/DF; Rcl 9705/SP; Rcl 9054/DF; Rcl 8641/CE; Rcl 8568/PE; Rcl 8373/RS; Rcl 8529/MS; Rcl 8368/CE; Rcl 9688/SP; Rcl 10119/SP; Rcl 9708/SP; Rcl 10000/SP; Rcl 10038/SP; Rcl 10036/SP; Rcl 9997/SP; Rcl 10104/SP; Rcl 10057/MS.
Banca Examinadora Decisões liminares: Rcl 5.460/SP; Rcl 5.508/SP; Rcl 8.226/DF; Rcl 7.411/DF; Rcl 6.224/SP; Rcl 8.858/SC; Rcl 9.888/RS; Rcl 9.455/SP; Rcl 9.399/PI; Rcl 9.330/SC; Rcl 8.954/SC; Rcl 8.975/SC; Rcl 8.559/SP; Rcl 8.976/SP; Rcl 8.949/SP; Rcl 8.489/SP; Rcl 7.
Resumo da Monografia


O propósito deste trabalho foi fazer uma análise do instituto da súmula vinculante a partir de um estudo sistemático das reclamações já julgadas em que tenha sido discutido o descumprimento de SV por decisão judicial ou ato administrativo. A partir dos resultados obtidos pela análise dos casos, traduzido em tabelas, tornou-se possível saber quais são as súmulas mais invocadas e as peculiaridades inerentes ao julgamento das reclamações em que aparecem. Com base no conhecimento de quais são essas súmulas vinculantes, a pesquisa buscou explorá-las a fim de saber se elas, individualmente, são eficazes ou não, para que, ao final, seja possível a traçar um diagnostico sobre como tem sido o desempenho, na prática, das súmulas vinculantes já editadas.